Skip to main content

Ideas about the budget and a few suggestions to boost the economy -- As written on 4th Feb 2013

I am having a diesel car for my own use but I do not mind if you increase the price of diesel to the extent that the companies who produce diesel at least do not make a loss. But besides a rise in inflation that would influence the decision to raise diesel prices, the decision should not burden a class of society that depend on it, raising interference from your allies. Alternatively, I can suggest that you increase the excise duty on diesel cars to compensate for the one lakh crore subsidy presently being paid by the government on diesel. Although lobby of diesel car manufacturing companies would not leave any stone unturned to stop you.

 My wife is very happy that the LPG cylinder that she uses is in fact 70% cheaper than its actual cost. I don’t mind if you tax her by raising LPG prices to the extent that LPG producing companies make a reasonable profit. I am certainly in favor of making LPG available to below middle class at a cheaper rate. You have to find out a solution for this. Just like you have put a cap of 6 cylinders per year per family, similarly LPG can be made available through ration shops at a cheaper rate.

 For the last 5 years Gold across the globe has been mis-marketed as a hedge against currency or country. I don’t know the real statistics behind it. But I know it has become the major culprit in economical growth of my country. As per Mr. C. Rangrajan  current account deficit has risen to 4.6 % in first half of current fiscal due to massive imports of Gold. It is a non productive investment. Thus you must raise import duty on Gold as huge budgetary deficit has become a major hindrance in growth.

 I got to know that out of our total population of 125 crore people there are only 3.25 crore tax payers. Out of this only 12 lakh people fall in the category of Rs.10 to 20 lakhs Income per year and just 3.5 lakh people in the bracket of the above Rs.20 lakhs Income per year category. These numbers of tax payers are less than 27.33 lakhs population of your very posh neighbourhood South Delhi alone. In 2000-2001, 2.5 crore people paid taxes. This number exceed nominally to just 3.24 crore tax payers in 2010/2011. Also our per capita GDP grew to USD 2000 last year compared to USD 450 in 2001. Therefore, widening your tax net would be a wise move. 45% of USA citizens pay taxes as opposed to only 3% in India.

 I am as fearful as you are citing the chances of our ratings being downgraded to Junk status by International Rating Agency. But I, probably like you, am masking a brave face but praying that it does not happen.  Therefore you need to kick start the investment cycle once again and do its fiscal consolidation soon.

External Debt has skyrocketed. Our foreign exchange reserves cover 80 % of our debt presently as against 110% just three years ago. You need to encourage exports by leaps and bounds.Faster implementation DTC AND GST would be a boon to the country. It is understood that Implementation of GST alone will add 1 % to GDP.

Since you do not provide any social security to retired people thus you should raise deduction under 80cc to 3 lakhs against 1 lakh now.Capital gain tax in shares has been a bone of contention between assessing officer and assesse. You should clarify short and long term capital gain tax. It will stop undue litigation and corruption.

 As written on 4th Feb 2013


  1. Thank you respected Vijay Kedia Sir for sharing Beautiful and Intelligent thoughts with all . Personally I'm indebted for you showing how to use Yahoo Finance .With due regards
    Vakharia Mahesh

  2. your the best master i could learn from thank you for sharing your experiences & your wise thoughts.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What I Have Learnt So Far From The Stock Market

Smoking may kill you in 20 years, but trading in stock futures can kill you the next day

Article published in the Economic Times  online on the 22nd of May 2018

From the days of open outcry trading under a banyan tree to high-speed trading in the iconic PJ Tower, the Indian stock market has surely come a long way. 

From being nowhere in 1990 to the world-class infrastructure for securities trading that we have today and Sebi putting up a robust regulatory mechanism, it has been an impressive journey. 
What is not impressive is the fact that the advantage of all this modern infrastructure and systems has mainly gone to four intermediaries, the regulators and exchanges themselves besides, of course, the tax department and brokers. The traders at large were poor back then and have still remained poor. Only a handful of them have become successful in this journey, that also in investing, not trading. Success percentage in trading is hardly 1 per cent. 
Why? Because, it’s not in our DNA. We learn things three ways: by birth when it comes in our DNA; in our childhood through school…

If you follow certain principles in stock market, then the worst situation in market is the best situation to invest- Written on 6th June 2012

It seems to be the beginning of a new bull market. Economy turns around after six months of turning around of stock market. Market reacts to any situation before the economy.
1990 was the worst year in Indian recent economy history. In 1990 we were 270 billion USD economy. But although our economy has grown four times since then, the phase of 2012 is compared to that of 1990. Today the Indian economy is more than 1 trillion USD. Savings rate in India is dropping YOY on higher GDP YOY.
Factors like inflation, interest rate, IIP, GDP, politics, investment sentiments are all against the economy, most of them being on the mercy of political will. Many stocks are at historically cheaper valuation. But, one cannot go wrong in consumer stocks. Since 1990 we have crossed three stages. India is at the third stage of savings pattern.  From a high saving rate with low income to high savings rate to higher income to currently (falling) low savings rate to higher income. Our savings rate has falle…